Our cruise on the Carnival Vista was a great vacation, but the overall experience had us considering switching over to Royal Caribbean. I missed the Royal Caribbean ships with all the things to do. We decided to go out of Galveston again just so we didn't have to mess with the hassle of flying to Florida for a cruise. Luckily, we decided to go on another cruise right when they were having a Kids Sail Free and 2nd Adult 60% Off sale, so we got a pretty good deal for this cruise given we were only 5 months out from sailing when we booked it. We then discovered that, after this trip, I would only be 15 nights away from Ryan and I each getting 4 free drinks per day on Royal Caribbean cruises!
Royal Caribbean Mariner of the Seas Review
This was actually the biggest ship I've ever been on, and yet it was only about 8,000 gross tons bigger than the Carnival Vista, yet it felt much bigger. I think the way that Royal Caribbean designs the inside of their ships is what makes them feel better. The best comparison I can think of is how much bigger homes feel when they have an open-concept kitchen and living space compared to separate spaces. Mariner just felt more open and easier to navigate than the Vista.
The Rooms on Royal Caribbean Mariner of the Seas
We love to get balcony rooms. I think it's partially because my husband and I are homebodies, so enjoying where we're staying is important to us. But also, traveling with a toddler means you spend a lot more time in your room, and that little extra space goes a long way. Unfortunately, our balcony door was squeaky so we weren't able to utilize it during nap time like we did on our Carnival cruise (Carnival has a door that swings open whereas Royal Caribbean has a sliding door).
Mariner of the Seas common areas were updated in 2018, but the rooms were not and you could kind of tell because the style of the room looked dated, our door was a pale pink. Our room also felt a little smaller on Royal Caribbean because our Carnival room was able to fit a Pack n Play and a coffee table, but there was no coffee table in our Royal Caribbean room.


Our room had 2 plugs at the vanity area and 1 plug in the bathroom. There was a phone by the bed, but apparently the plug was behind the wall because we couldn't find a plug behind or near the bed. I was very happy I had brought a
European outlet adapter so we were able to have 3 plugs in the bedroom. I was also glad that I brought a
portable iPhone and Apple Watch charger bank that could charge our devices on our night stands like what we're used to back home. I had brought a plug-in dusk-to-dawn nightlight for the bathroom plug, but it seemed the outlet only worked when the bathroom light switch was on, which defeated the purpose of the nightlight.
Eating on Royal Caribbean Mariner of the Seas
Because we were traveling with an almost-two-year-old, the My Time dining made the most sense to us, as it would allow us to keep her normal 7pm dinner time while still getting to eat in a dining room instead of a buffet. This turned out to be a mistake. On our Carnival cruise, we were able to just put our name on the waitlist as we were getting ready for dinner, and a table would usually be ready by the time we got down to the dining room. Royal also had the My Time dining in the same room as the early and late dinners, just on a different floor, whereas on Carnival the My Time dining room was on a different part of the ship than the main dining room.
For Royal Caribbean, we actually had to make reservations before our sail date, and unfortunately by the time I learned this the earliest dinner reservations were 8pm, which is our daughter's normal bedtime. Pushing her dinner to 8 wouldn't be as bad if dinner itself wasn't an hour ordeal. Thankfully, on Day 1 we went to the main dining room and were able to talk to someone who helped us get a reservation for 6:40 every night. This turned out great, as we had the same table and same waiter every night whereas on Carnival we had a different table and different waitstaff each night. This was so helpful for us as after the first night the waitstaff learned our daughter's preferences and would anticipate her needs before we even asked. For example, when your kid is seated they immediately bring out a bowl of diced fruit as an appetizer to help keep your kid entertained while they wait for their entree. Our assistant waiter noticed our daughter only ate the strawberries and that we asked for more strawberries, so every night after that he only brought her a big bowl of strawberries and she was a happy girl. We liked the food we had each night and often tried a two entrees or appetizers.
We ate most of our breakfasts and lunches at the Windjammer buffet, which was a mistake our first port day. We circled the whole room twice and finally found a seat sharing a giant table with another family, but had to spend more time trying to find a clean high chair. Next cruise, we'll stick with the main dining room for port days since everyone seems to be on the same schedule of eating right before they let us off the ship. On sea days, it wasn't so bad since everyone was on different schedules and their mealtimes were more spread out. I noticed between the breakfast we had at the main dining room seemed to be all of the options given at the Windjammer, just that the Windjammer had more options. But, the Windjammer only had pre-made omelets with ham or cheese, and the main dining room had create-your-own omelets as an option. We got mimosas on the first breakfast at the Windjammer, and both the orange and strawberry mimosas were made with cheap-tasting champagne so we didn't like them.
We had lunch one day at the Cafe Promenade because they had pizza which is a quick go-to to get our daughter fed. There were also little finger sandwich options if you didn't want pizza. Cafe Promenade is weird because the food in it is free, but it's right across the hallway from a bar that doesn't have free food, so it's hard to know what is free and what isn't. We also grabbed breakfast there too, they just had breads and breakfast sandwiches. The selection was small, but the food was pretty good, it seemed more geared towards coffee and tea drinkers.
On our last sea day, we had lunch at Johnny Rockets. You pay $18 and then can get whatever you want off the menu, but milkshakes cost extra. It is a small room, but it took them forever to find us a clean high chair. We ordered, got my root beer float (so good!) and onion rings (amazing!! great ranch, they need to make fried pickles!!) before we got her highchair. The burgers were good, Ryan said the 12 burger "special sauce" seemed to just be ketchup and Tabasco mixed together.
What to do on Royal Caribbean Mariner of the Seas
Given that we had signed up for
The Key, it was easier for us to do activities like the rock wall climbing and Flow Rider since we had reserved times. I volunteered to be the babysitter while my husband was the adventurer doing all the things.
We did the Mini Golf together the morning of our first port day, and it had such a great view as we were pulling into port! I recommend the Mariner Dunes area as a great place for a sail-away view or to watch as you sail into port. The Mini Golf was a cute little ocean-themed course, and was easy for kids to do.
We went to the ice show "Under the Big Top" and really liked it! It's 45 minutes, but the first part is loud and flashy, which scared our toddler. The rink has 2 long sides and 1 short side, and the front row of the 1 short side had a lot of audience involvement. Keep this in mind if you have small children that might be afraid of people running and jumping at them.
We spent the vast majority of our time in the open-play toddler room. It was huge and had a surprising amount of baby and toddler toys. Our daughter loved to play in here, and we were happy to be able to sit down and relax because she's old enough for independent play. But of course we spent a lot of time playing pretend for her and looking up whether we should buy her favorite pretend food truck toy.
When our daughter was in the paid drop-off child care, we loved the Solarium! It was a much better experience than the adults-only area on our Carnival cruise. It was quiet, kid free, had 2 hot tubs, a good size pool, lots of chairs and even day beds both in the shade and sun, the bar was never packed even on sea days, and there were waiters taking drink orders and occasionally a beer cart would come by.
5 Night Western Caribbean Cruise Itinerary
Puerto Costa Maya, Mexico
I think this was my first time at this stop. I tried looking up my past cruise itineraries, but Royal Caribbean only saves them for 7 years and apparently I haven't sailed with them in less than 7 years. Yet another reason why I have this blog. My mom told me she's been here on a cruise, and thinks I was with her on it, but I honestly can't remember. The port itself is actually really nice, we saw 2 pools (at least 1 I noticed had a swim-up bar) that seemed free, and several restaurants and a lot of shopping. I honestly think this is one of those ports where you can get by without an excursion just hanging out at the port. The day we were there, we were the only ship so it didn't feel overcrowded at all. We didn't get there until noon and had to leave by 6:30, so it was a short trip. Getting there at that time meant that we were walking through the port at a very hot time of the day, which wasn't ideal. I didn't have time to take photos of the actual port because we were rushing to make sure we made it to the meet up point on time, since a toddler slows us down, but I did grab photos on the way out.
 |
Our daughter fell asleep so we carried her trike since we didn't bring the trike backpack
|
None of the excursions offered through Royal Caribbean seemed like something we'd want to do with our daughter, so we did our excursion outside of the cruise line. We dabbled with this in
Belize and really realized that you can get a lot more of your time out of your stop if your excursion is catered specifically to
you rather than a group, so we felt like we could do it again. This experience was better than Belize because we had it booked well in advance.
We ended up booking a day at
Maya Chan. We paid $79 per adult and $19 for our toddler via PayPal, and got all-inclusive food and drinks plus a free ride to the beach. What's nice is that it's ran by Americans, so there was no communication barrier when booking, and they sent lots of follow-up emails leading up to the day with confirmation of our reservation and information on how to find them on the day of and what to do, so I felt very reassured doing this on our own.
It was a little intimidating doing it this way because usually if you do an excursion through your cruise, you'll all meet as a group either on the ship or immediately off the ship and then all go to your excursion together, and Maya Chan did a really good job of trying to make it similar to that. They emailed us a map to exit the port (it is a pretty big port) and walk to a meet up spot. The map and instructions were pretty detailed and we felt fairly confident figuring out where to go. Just keep left after the dolphin area, don't continue on into the shops. They say it's a 1/4 mile, but in that heat it felt like half a mile. We were so happy we brought our
Doona trike for our daughter, there's no way she could've made it without having to hold her if we didn't bring it. I'm also glad I had a
stroller fan attached to it for her, because even though she wasn't walking, she was dripping sweat by the time we got to the meetup. I just wish we brought our
neck fans because we were dying pushing her and carrying all our beach stuff in the heat since most of the walk is uncovered. I also wish we had brought our
trike backpack because we had to carry her stroller around the rest of the trip.

We got there and within a minute we were given paper wristbands and then a van took about 10 of us to the beach. It was about a 20-30 minute ride with traffic, but it was worth the effort! This was a perfect excursion with our toddler. Right when you get there, they have a wall of life vests in all sizes (small enough to fit our 25-pound toddler), snorkel masks, and leftover toys that prior families had left behind. We were given ice-cold filtered water, the Wi-Fi password (there's 2 Wi-Fi options, one for the Bar and one for the Beach so you have a great connection wherever you are and they're the same password for both), and then were taken to our area.
Our area was PERFECT! A huge covered area that had 4 Adirondack chairs, 2 tables, a daybed, and a hammock! All just for the 3 of us. I had brought my baby Bogg Bag specifically so that I could use the little
tray insert to have an extra table for all our stuff, but didn't even need it.
We hadn't even sat down all our stuff when we were given the best rum punch welcome drinks I've ever had, and they even had a fruit punch version for our daughter. Right after that, we were given homemade tortilla chips and fresh pico de gallo and guacamole. They do use small 8-ounce cups like a lot of all inclusive resorts do, so I recommend you bring an
insulated tumbler so your drink doesn't run out as fast. They were the best pina coladas we had ever had, and that's my husband's go-to vacation drink. The drinks didn't taste very strong (probably because they were so flavorful with the fresh pineapples), but when I asked for a double it was a little too strong.


The ocean was nice, but for our time of the year the sea grass was definitely present. They had 2 guys on the beach and in the water trying to rake it away, but there was just so much that they weren't able to make a lot of progress. Once you got out a little ways, there was no seagrass. I wore my
water sandals into the water because I don't love stepping on textured surfaces in open water, but I wish I'd worn my
water socks instead because when I walked over/through the seagrass, some got stuck between my foot and sandals and it freaked me out. But, the water was nice and warm and they provided floating chairs on a first-come-first-serve basis, the water was nice and calm so safe for littles with the use of their provided life vests, and you could even see our ship from the beach! The beach was secluded in a jungle area and we didn't see anyone else at the beach. They also let you use their snorkel masks, stand up paddle boards, and kayaks for free. ]

For the people who didn't want to deal with the seagrass, they did have a pool. It was about half the size of a backyard pool. Unfortunately, a lot kids took the floating chairs into the pool which basically took up the entire pool, so we didn't feel we could squeeze in and try it out. The bathrooms were right by the pool.
 |
The pool is bigger than this angle makes it look |
Their service was the best service we've ever had. Lots of people always walking around in case you needed them, and occasionally they'd ask if you need something, but it was the perfect balance of being attentive without being annoying. They would even come into the ocean to serve the drinks. And one time I was going to the bar area anyways so I just went to ask for a refill myself and the bartender instantly recognized my cup and asked if I wanted another pina colada. They confirmed our cruise line and ship name, and then let us know they could take us back 70, 60, or 50 minutes before our boarding time, and then gave us a 15-minute warning before our ride was ready back.
What I really appreciated about this excursion as a toddler mom was that it wasn't a party atmosphere like a lot of places are on vacation. There was some music at the bar, but even at the bar it wasn't loud and you could easily have a conversation. Since we didn't get to port until after our daughter's lunch time, we had already eaten before we got off the ship so we didn't eat the provided lunch, but the chips we snacked on a bit were really good so I do think their lunch was also probably really good. The only kids we saw there were elementary aged or younger. Teenagers probably wouldn't love this place if they wanted a lot to do. But, I thought it was the perfect relaxing place and I would love to go there again just to sit and read a book with a drink in my hand. If I can't do that, then I'm just as happy to come back with our toddler and let her have a great day at her pace just playing in the water and the sand and taking naps on the beach.
Cozumel, Mexico
This was our second trip to
Cozumel in two years (cruising out of Galveston will do that to ya), so I was so excited to put my daughter in the same outfit she wore the last time she was here. Last time, we just hung out at the Carnival port and did a little shopping and a little eating before going back on the ship. We were here from 7:30 until 4:30, so we had a good long day here.
 |
2023
|
 |
2024 |
Similar to Costa Maya, we didn't really see a great toddler-friendly excursion offered by Royal Caribbean, so we booked
Nachi Cocom on our own. We paid $69 per adult and $0 for our toddler to again get all-inclusive food and drinks. The reason we chose Nachi Cocom over other Cozumel options like Paradise Beach or Mr. Sanchos was that they limit the amount of guests per day. Having a toddler, it was really important to me that she felt she could run and play without getting trampled by a huge crowd. It also didn't have any big water inflatables that attract big kids who can run around and run over my daughter.
Navigating the Cozumel port to get to Nachi Cocum was an easier experience than navigating the Costa Maya port to get to Maya Chan. We again brought our
Doona trike and this time remembered the
trike backpack, but my husband thinks our daughter could have made the walk.We just followed the signs that pointed towards the taxi pickup. The one sus part was at the end there was a sign pointing to go to the right to get to the taxis, and then right behind that was a store with a sign pointing to the left down a hallway to get to the taxis. We thought this was a scam and went right, but actually you do go take a right until you get to the store and then take a left and go down the hallway to the taxis. What I appreciated about the taxi pickup was that they had a board with prices to the major tourist areas with a flat rate per 4 people. Whereas in Cancun all the taxis are white with a green stripe, here all the taxis were white with a red stripe, so you could feel comfortable knowing you're getting into a legit taxi. The trip was only about 20 minutes to get to the beach.

Once you get there, they have you take a welcome photo and then later they offered us to buy it for $12. It was a cute photo, and I'm glad we bought it because with the chaos of a toddler we completely forgot to buy photos from our ship until after we got home, so this was our only professional photo of the trip. They then will take you to complete your payment and then give you paper wristbands and let you know who your waiter will be and then your taken to your beach chairs. There's actually a QR code that you need to scan to connect to Wi-Fi that we missed and had to go back, because the waiter we asked for the Wi-Fi code either didn't know it or wouldn't give it to us, so don't forget to scan the code before you leave. The Wi-Fi worked much better at the pool than at the beach. We were seated by the beach bar which made me nervous at first for nap times, but thankfully they didn't have the music too loud.
What was the only con of our Nachi Cocom experience was that the beach area they brought us to initially had a big umbrella covering 4 beach chairs and a table, but as we were setting our stuff down, they took away the 2 beach chairs, leaving only 2 beach chairs for the 3 of us. I know that our daughter was free, but she still deserved to have her own chair and I wasn't a fan of this. At first I was just thinking they were rationing the chairs so that later-arriving guests could have a seat, but the chairs just sat out in the middle of the sun unoccupied for the rest of the day. The table they left us with was small, so I was very happy that I brought my baby Bogg Bag with my little
tray insert to have an extra table so not everything had to go in the sand.

The beach was also large and didn't seem to have a lot of sea grass, but I do recommend
water sandals because there are a lot of shells. I'm glad we brought a
little mesh bag for our daughter to collect shells in. There was no beach toys or floats offered, so make sure you bring your won. They have showers at the bathrooms to the right of the beach bar to wash off ocean water, and they have a food wash station near the pool to wash off sand.
Nachi Cocom isn't a resort, but it does have a resort-sized pool. It was huge with a very large shallow ledge for adults to sit and talk or toddlers to play, an adults-only hot tub, and a swim-up bar. This was were my toddler wanted to spend the majority of the day, and we were just fine with that.
Around the pool was a bunch of outdoor dining tables, so we had lunch by the pool. There was a good variety of options, and I really liked the food. The mixed drinks weren't the strongest, so we just stuck with beer to save on the empty calories. I never saw water sitting out like at Maya Chan, so I was glad we brought several bottled waters with us off the ship.
 |
Regular menu
|
 |
Kids menu |
When it was time to go, they ordered a taxi for us and it was there about 5 minutes later. Overall, I think this would be a great sit and read a good book with a drink in your hand excursion. They specifically have signs saying they don't allow "spring break" behavior. Like Maya Chan, it seemed to be the perfect place for early elementary kids and younger to just hang out and enjoy the beach or the pool. We'd definitely come here again, but next time I do want to talk to them about having 1 beach chair per person rather than 1 beach chair per paying adult.
Overall thoughts on this cruise
This trip was much better than our quick 2-night stay in Cancun, but felt just a little too short compared to our last 7-night cruise. But, we had a great time! It was definitely easier traveling with our daughter now that she can walk and explore the ship, but more exhausting because all she wanted to do was go up and down the stairs. Meals were also much easier with her being able to eat table food the whole time and not having to worry about formula and filtered water.
Our next trip
Ryan and I have agreed
after going to an all-inclusive and then this cruise within a month that we just really prefer cruises right now. There's so much more variety of food to eat and things to do on a cruise, especially with a small kid.
We really wanted to book our next cruise while on this ship (I'm only 15 nights away from Diamond status, which gets us each 4 free drinks a day!), but we're still at the growing stage of our family, and you can only cruise up until 26 weeks in your pregnancy. It just seems too soon to book a cruise when we don't know if/when I'll be pregnant before the next cruise. But, once we have that information sorted, we're on board to cruise again soon.
We have pretty much committed to being Loyal to Royal from the elevated experience you get with them. We're not completely against Carnival, and have even talked about going on the Vista again to stay in one of their Havana extended balcony rooms that has a little courtyard as a balcony (how perfect for babies!!). But, we do think we're ready for a break from Western Caribbean itineraries. I'm thinking our next cruise should go to Coco Cay because I haven't been there since they did their big renovation, and Ryan has never been there. I'm also itching to go on a larger ship, especially with little ones. I think our daughter would have loved being able to play on a splash pad on the cruise, so I'm starting to look at what the ships offer that would be best for them.
And for our next trip.... we're going to
Disney!